Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Book Group Meeting 4

The final section of Kohn's book looks at the notion of moving beyond rewards. If rewards don't work, what does?


He presents us with a series of ideas to create the motivating conditions, both in the workplace and in the classroom. In the workplace, he suggests:

  1. Abolish Incentives: Kohn neatly summarises this by providing an anecdote from his own, self-employed experiences, writing, '[w]hat I attempt to do ... is decouple the task from the compensation'. (p.183)
  2. Reevaluate Evaluation: Kohn stresses here the importance of evaluation being used as a way of 'helping employees do better work' (p. 185). He suggests that a programme of evaluation should have four features: it is a two-way conversation; it is a continuous process; it never involves relative ranking or competition; it is not connected with compensation.
  3. Create the Conditions for Authentic Motivation: Kohn quotes Princeton University economist, Alan S. Blinder: 'Changing the way workers are treated may boost productivity more than changing the way they are paid' (Paying for Productivity: A Look at the Evidence). Kohn makes four suggestions for things people in managerial positions ought to do: watch, by looking for problems and helping people solve them; listen, by seriously and respectfully attending to the concerns of workers; talk, by providing plenty of informational feedback; think, by reflecting on your managerial style and considering whether you are relying on extrinsic motivators.
In schools, Kohn main argument it that, wherever possible, grades should be removed. He has seven practical suggestions (p. 208-209) for doing so:
  1. Limit the number of assignments for which you give a letter or number grade.
  2. Limit the number of gradations, for example, move from A/B/C/D/F to check-plus/check/check-minus.
  3. Reduce the number of grades to two: A and Incomplete. It neutralizes the effect of grades because it presumes any work that does not merit an A isn't finished yet; learning takes precedence over sorting. 
  4. Never grade students while they are still learning something. This removes the opportunity for students to have 'time to be tentative' (p. 208).
  5. Never grade for effort. Kohn argues that grades by their nature reduce motivation. In addition, he suggests: 'rewarding or punishing the child's efforts conveniently allows educators to ignore the possibility that the curriculum or learning environment may just have something to do with his or her lack of enthusiasm' (p. 209)
  6. Never grade on a curve.
  7. Bring students in on the evaluation process. Kohn cites research by Mark Lepper that one's 'perception of competence at an activity will depend [on] ... whether one has to succeed by his or her own standards or by someone else's' (p. 209).
Kohn also links the idea of the 3 Cs as crucial to motivating employees and students alike. These are:
  • Collaboration: learn together, work together.
  • Content: curriculum, and people's jobs, must be engaging, purposeful and relevant.
  • Choice: autonomy and self-determination motivates in the workplace and the classroom.
We will discuss these ideas, and others, in the final book group meeting on Kohn's Punished by Rewards. Some key questions include:
  1. To what extent do you agree with the ideas above?
  2. What are the pitfalls or difficulties of implementing these ideas?
  3. What practices can (and should) you change as a teacher and/or leader?
  4. What motivates you?
And, for a different point of view, check out this article about Kohn by Daniel Willingham. Kohn's own response to it can be found at the end of the article.

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Motivation and Mastery

Motivation and Mastery

The book group focused its conversation on a number of debatable issues. These included:

  1. Can you motivate someone, or is this a quality inherent to a person? Can we only manipulate, control or create the appearance of motivation? If we can't motivate, how do we create the conditions for people to develop their own intrinsic motivation? Do we have the time to allow this to happen organically?
  2. Given Kohn's view on grading, what would the ideal set of reports look like? Can we as a school escape the unwanted demands of 'higher' institutions (employers and universities) to create a system that is best supported by known educational research?
  3. What does Kohn's book have to say about merit pay? 

One spin off conversation from question 2 was looking at the increasing amount of content made available online, for free. Much has been written about Khan Academy, iTunes U or TEDed, and a number of universities are now opening up content to their courses. One company has gone a step further. The BBC recently produced a report on Udacity, a company set-up within Stanford offering tutored, certificated courses for free, online. 

Stanford already had a large presence on iTunes U, but the model offered by this company is somewhat different. Though Udacity is not affiliated with Stanford, the implications of its existence are fascinating. Udacity already claims to have 100,000 users. It suggests that it is able to offer an economically viable model of free, online and, certificated education without socio-economic ('I can't afford it') or physical ('I can't get there') boundaries. In theory, companies like Udacity who are offering non-exclusive higher education could create positive trickle down effects in schools. There are no barriers to signing up for a course other than your motivation and your prior knowledge. If you wish to learn, learn, unhindered by economic restraints or the need to acquire numerous qualifications as social currency. Mastery becomes the motivation, not collecting marketable qualifications.


It is worthwhile considering some of the long-term implications of such courses. Are we witnessing a new fad in education that will disappear as soon as it arrives, or is this the start of a sea-change in approach? If the latter, is it for the better, or will there be some unintended consequences?


Check out the videos below to explore this topic further. 


CNN Report here:



EdX report by Wall Street Journal here:





MITx Launch Video here:






Monday, May 21, 2012

Book Group Meeting 3



In our third book group meeting, we will debate some of the following points. What are your thoughts?

Points for Debate
o  Motivation. You cannot motivate people, but can only set up certain conditions that will develop their interest in what they are doing and remove constraints.
o  Merit Pay. If we want to improve the quality of teaching at ISZL, we should follow the lead of some businesses and base pay increases on teacher performance appraisals and involvement in extra-curricular activities.
o  Awards. There is a place in schools for awards and rewards, especially rewards for good behaviour.
o  Report Cards. Some people want to get rid of grades on report cards and others say grades are the quickest and clearest way of telling parents how their children are doing in school. What would be the ideal reporting system?
o  Improvement. The best way to improve any educational system is to increase the length of the school day/year and to ensure that students have more set work to do at home.
o  Self-Esteem. Students are failing to learn because we’re afraid to let them know when they get something wrong for fear of injuring their self-esteem.
o  Consistency. Every teacher in ISZL should know what material is to be covered for their specific grade, when it should be covered, and how to evaluate their students’ performance.
o  Choice. The more a child feels part of the process, the more his/her point of view is solicited and taken seriously, the fewer the problems there will be.
o  Respect I. Experienced teachers sometime say that they are “not here to be liked”. A good way to gain respect and establish class discipline is to hand out detentions or ‘zeros’ for missing homework, perceived lack of effort in class, breaking classr rules or missing deadlines. If they start wit this early in the year, students won’t do it again later.
o  Respect II. Some teachers equate being a good teacher with being popular and being seen as a students’ friend. This may involve turning a blind eye to students not following minor school rules such as chewing gum or using their phones in order to avoid conflict.
o  Caring. More emphasis should be placed on teaching values. Students should learn to care, share, and help across different situations and with different people, including those they don’t know, don’t like, and don’t look like.
o  Rules. Rules have an important place in schools and it is the responsibility of the
adult to ensure that rules are fair, consistent and enforced.
o  Safety. A classroom that feels safe is one in which students are free to admit when they don’t understand something and are able to ask for help. Grades, tests, rewards and punishment are the enemies of safety as they reduce the probability that students will speak up.

Monday, May 14, 2012

Lures for Learning

Some time ago I received a comment on my own blog from a teacher whose Twitter name is @educatoral.  Mr G commented that when he asked students what they felt about doing away with awards at assemblies, the students were angry because they felt that they would not be appreciated if they did not get awards.  It's an interesting idea that in some cases it's the students themselves who want to continue with the awards.

Chapter 8 in Punished by Rewards is all about why behaviorism doesn't work in the classroom.  Alfie Kohn starts by writing that students when they first arrive at school are enthusiastic and fascinated by learning, however after some years they come to see learning as a chore.  He writes that "if children's enthusiasm is smothered, it is a direct result of something that happens in our schools."

In every school I've worked at I've seen rewards used in one form or another.  The idea behind them is that this motivates the students and improves their performance.  I've also worked at schools where the idea of rewarding teachers for their performance has been suggested.  I left the UK in the 1980s, thankfully, before the 1990s system of inspecting schools was introduced  - OFSTED.  Friends of mine who were still teaching there told me stories of OFSTED visits and how the schools were assessed and then graded on a scale.  League tables of schools were published.  Schools which were judged as "inadequate" were then put into "special measures" - something that it seemed should be avoided at all costs as it allowed teachers, head teachers and the governing body to be dismissed.  I was interested to read the results after almost 20 years of OFSTED visits to schools:  the number of outstanding schools has decreased from 19% to 9% and the number of schools judged to be inadequate has risen from 4% to 10% (figures from March 2010).  Clearly rewarding the "best" schools and "punishing" the worst does not seem to have achieved very much in terms of learning! (In the meantime every single one of my friends who started teaching with me in the UK has now left the profession so clearly this wasn't very motivating for them either.)

Getting back to the main argument about what motivates students to learn, it's clear that they don't need a lot of artificial incentives in order to motivate them.  Alfie Kohn points out 3 facts about motivation:

  1. Young children don't need to be rewarded to learn - the desire to learn itself is natural.  Pre-schoolers and kindergartners have a great deal of intrinsic motivation, though as they move through elementary school their approach to learning becomes increasingly extrinsic.
  2. At any age, rewards are less effective than intrinsic motivation for promoting effective learning - there is a positive correlation between intrinsic motivation and academic achievement.  Students who are interested and engaged will generally succeed academically.  Our aim is that students will move from being excited about their learning at school to following these interests outside of school - children's attitudes towards learning are the most important indicators of success.
  3. Rewards for learning undermine intrinsic motivation - rewards lead to a decline of interest.
Kohn goes on to write about what demotivates students.  Studies have shown that being controlled and forced into a pre-established curriculum works against motivation (which is good news for PYP schools that focus on student inquiry as a way of constructing knowledge - this approach must be more motivating for students).   Kohn writes:
Telling students exactly what they have to do, or using extrinsic incentives to get them to do it, often contributes to feelings of anxiety and even helplessness ... [which] are associated with lower-quality performance.
Now this is the interesting part, which brings me back to Mr G's findings when he asked his students about their feelings on getting rid of awards:  a student's need for rewards "is a reflection of how much s/he has been controlled by rewards and punishments in the past."

Studies of both special education and gifted programmes have shown that rewards lead to lower achievements:  "students led to think mostly about how well they are doing - or even worse, how well they are doing compared to everyone else - are less likely to do well."  Focusing on performance also increases a student's fear of failure:  "Anything that gets children to think primarily about their performance will undermine their interest in learning, their desire to be challenged, and ultimately the extent of their achievement."

Motivate and achieve are two key words in the school's mission statement.  I think these are both wonderful ideals to be working towards and think it's great that we are reading Alfie Kohn's Punished by Rewards so that we can discuss how to effectively motivate students in order that they can achieve their true potential.

Bribes for Behaving

As teachers we talk about the necessity of students developing 21st century skills.  These are things like creativity and critical thinking, questioning, collaboration and so on.  We also talk a lot about students developing responsibility, becoming caring, developing self-confidence, being open-minded and so on.  In the PYP these attributes are embedded in the learner profile and in the attitudes that we want students to  demonstrate.  Alfie Kohn writes that rewards and punishments are worthless for helping students develop these values and skills because all they do is produce temporary compliance, rather than building good values.  He writes:
A child who complies in the hope of getting a reward or avoiding a punishment is not, as we sometimes say, "behaving himself."  It would be more accurate to say the reward or punishment is behaving him.
It's interesting that when students are asked what they think good behavior is, they mention things such as following the rules, keeping quiet, not moving around too much, keeping busy with their work and sticking to the schedule.  They see the teacher's role as maintaining discipline, rather than helping students to be reflective or caring.  However Kohn writes, "children do not learn to be moral by learning to obey roles that others make for them."

Some years ago I read a book called "Grounded for Life" which was about how to communicate better with teenagers.  This book proposes that young people who misbehave suffer the logical or natural consequences of their behavior.  For example if a teenager doesn't do homework, the natural consequence is that they receive a lower grade, if the teenager forgets to bring in a permission slip for a trip, the natural consequence is that the student misses the trip.  One of the things I liked about this book is that it clearly asks:  whose problem is this?  It recommends stepping back and being interested and understanding, but not anxious - don't try to lessen the results the negative consequences bring.  The argument here is that as adults we learn by the natural consequences of what we do and these consequences can be used to teach children too.

Ultimately we would like students to be ethical and to avoid doing certain things because they know these actions will have a negative or hurtful affect on themselves or others.  Kohn argues that punishment doesn't contribute to such values, because it just teaches that if students are caught doing something forbidden they will suffer the consequences.  He argues:
Teaching children to think about the consequences (to themselves) of doing something wrong does nothing to nurture a lasting commitment to good values.
In the same way we would like students to be caring towards others, however Kohn shows that the evidence is that students who are rewarded for being caring are less likely to think of themselves as caring or compassionate people.  This is because rewards punish:
It is no less controlling to offer goodies for a desired behavior than to threaten sanctions for its absence.
Good behavior and good values, it seems, are two completely different things.  Rewards and punishments may in the short term encourage good behavior, but Kohn writes that they will never encourage good values.

Pay for Performance

Chapter 10 of Punished by Rewards by Alfie Kohn deals with workplace motivation.  The first part of this chapter is about how compensations systems can act as barriers to quality, productivity and motivation.  Daniel Pink has said the best use of money is to "pay people enough to get the issue of money off the table ... so they are not thinking about the money, they are thinking about the work." and that what really motivates people is autonomy, mastery and purpose.  Alfie Kohn also writes the same thing:  "Pay people generously and equitably.  Do your best to make sure they don't feel exploited.  Then do everything in your power to help them put money out of their minds."  Kohn writes that the big problem with money is the way it is used to control people.

Further on in the chapter Kohn writes about evaluation and how this too can be a demotivator.  At one school I remember we changed the term "teacher evaluation" (which implied making a value judgement about someone's performance) to "teacher appraisal" which apparently was a more positive term to use because it contained the word "praise" instead of the word "value".  In this school we were appraised on our goals, most of which we set ourselves.  I've never worked in a place where evaluation or appraisal has been linked to pay, but I have worked in places where it has been suggested that such a compensation scheme might be introduced.  However what I have noticed is that any evaluation or appraisal scheme, regardless of what it is called, seems to generate a climate of anxiety and fear among teachers being appraised, which could indicate that it is being used for the wrong purpose.

Alfie Kohn addresses some of the reasons why schools and companies have such systems:  some are used to determine pay, awards etc.  Some may be introduced to try to make employees perform better (fear or negative evaluation, hope of positive evaluation), some may be to decide who is doing a good job so that they can be promoted to something better, some may be to provide feedback, discuss problems and help employees to do a better job.  Of those, it seems only the last reason is likely to be useful.  In the case of promotion, Kohn argues that employees are made to feel like failures if they are not upwardly mobile - or perhaps if they choose not to be.  Kohn also points out that appraisals of someone's performance in their current job are no real indicator of how they will perform in a different position and he also writes that performance is best judged by the evaluation of one's peers and not one's superiors.

Evaluations and appraisals can be useful ways of helping someone to do better work, however, especially when this involves a dialogue and not a judgment.  They are also useful when they are ongoing, rather than just a once or twice a year observation.  However the most interesting part of the chapter that I've read so far relates to the relationship between the two people involved - Kohn writes that it is foolish to have someone "serving in the self-conflicting role as a counselor (helping someone improve performance) when at the same time, he or she is presiding as a judge."

The crux of this part of the book is that it is changing the way that employees are treated (as opposed to paid) that boosts productivity and motivation and in my experience this is certainly true.

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Book Group Meeting Two - A Summary



In our latest book group meeting, we discussed the first section of Kohn's book. We covered some of the following points:

  • Kohn is very subjective, which can distract from the qualities of his argument  

  • university entrance remains very focused on test scores. 

  •  free will vs. determinism. 

  • enrichment v. mastery. 

  • connection to Tiger Mother. 

  • how praise/rewards/punishments can really rupture relationships.

The following questions were also raised:

  • how do the concepts raised by Kohn relate to our own education? 

  • what is the connection to parenting? 

  • relevance to "Drive" by Dan Pink? 

  • why is pop behaviorism so popular? 

  • how can we experiment as a teacher when giving feedback? How neutral can I be? 

  • Kohn really attacks behaviorism.  Does he create a convincing arugment that it is morally wrong to manipulate? 

  • are we all addicted to grades?  How do we make the focus on ways to grow instead? 

  • what are the non-negotiables in our curriculum? Do we treat them as such? 

  •  what if an entire school doesn't share this same philosophy? Are we unified in constructing and maintaining this ethos?  Do we have something that transcends individual differences of opinion?
Posted on behalf of Malia